Sylvie Rochon's lawyer emphasizes that the scale of the response cannot be compared to that of the attack because her client felt in danger.
A person in this situation is likely to make errors of judgment in the force that is required, she told jurors.
She asks jurors to also question the fact that her client contacted the emergency services while her sister was still alive. Would she have made such a gesture if she had intended to kill her?, she emphasizes.
Me Elise Pinsonnault recalled that the prosecution was not able to demonstrate a motive, or to determine why Sylvie Rochon would have had an interest in killing her sister Denise Rochon ?
For his part, the Director of Criminal and Penal Prosecutions, represented by Me Philippe Comtois, considers that the testimony of Sylvie Rochon should be rejected by the members of the jury.
This is a totally implausible and not credible story.
A quote from Me Philippe Comtois
Sylvie Rochon is charged with 2nd degree murder. Me Comtois believes that the seriousness of the injuries suffered by Denise Rochon and the absence of injuries on the body of her sister Sylvie suggests that the fight was one-sided.
Is it reasonable to believe that Denise Rochon was beaten to death, he mentioned while addressing the jurors. Me Comtois specifies that the number of blows and the location of the blows suggest that death was desired. The victim had head trauma, 25 head lacerations, a torn ear, a fractured rib and a detached mandible, according to the pathologist who analyzed the victim.
Me Comtois also doubts Sylvie Rochon's version concerning the fact that she never recognized her sister during the battle she describes.
The members of the jury were released until Tuesday morning. Judge Jean-Louis Lemay, of the Superior Court, will then send them his instructions in the morning. They will then be isolated in order to render their decision.
Sylvie Rochon murder trial opens with jury selection