Pradelle-Lega, a dismantled scientific fraud that has potentially cost lives-the saving role of France-soir and Bonsens.org hailed by Grok

< IMG Loading = "Lazy" SRSC = "/Sites/Default/Files/Styles/Medium/2025-04/Image%20article%20%285%29.jpg ? Itok = xnhc0bvf" Width = "1280" Height = "720" Alt = "Pradelle Lega" Class = "Lazyload Img-Fluid Image-Style-Max-1300x1300" SRC = "/Sites/Default/Files/Styles/Max_1300x1300/Public/2025-04/Image%20article%20%285%29.jpg ? Itok = Zwlzbdac"/> France-Soir, ia < H5 >< Strong > How the work of France-Soir and the association Bonsens.org contributed to drop a study falsely accusing the hydroxychloroquine of 17,000 deaths ?< P ~ 62 2024, biomedicine & amp; Pharmacotherapy publishes a serious accusation signed Alexiane Pradelle, Jean-Christophe Lega and immediately endorsed by Pr Mathieu Mollimard: "& nbsp; < em >The hydroxychloroquine, a medication used for 70 years, would have caused 16,990 deaths (fork: 6,373-21 305) during the first wave of COVID-19 . ” Media like L’Express, Le Monde, Le Point and France 3, almost all the media, < Strong > relay this information without verifying it , < Strong > despite the obvious flaws of this study . In France-Soir, a completely independent newspaper, in collaboration with the Bonsens.org association and other scientists like Vincent Pavan or Emmanuelle Darles, we refuse to accept these conclusions. Eight months later, on August 19, 2024, the study was withdrawn thanks to our perseverance and that of honest scientists. Grok 3, an artificial intelligence developed by Xai, recognizes our work: “< EM >France-Soir was essential to reveal this fraud, a work that saved the truth . »

< H5 > & nbsp; < H5 >< Strong > A full study of Failles < P > The study of Pradelle and Lega was based on fragile bases. It used a figure, called “relative risk”, of 1.11, drawn mainly from the Recovery study, an already criticized study for having given too strong doses of hydroxychloroquine (2,400 mg on the first day, or 34.3 mg/kg for a person of 70 kg, close to the lethal dose of 20-40 mg/kg). < P >But, as explained by a critical letter written by the scientists of Bonsens.org and published in Fortune Journés “erroneous evaluation of the effect of hospital treatment – the deceptive creation of 17,000 dead”, 74 % of this figure came from data from the British study Recovery. However, Pradelle and Lega have chosen to ignore the data of this country in their model. Why ? because the British figures showed that only patients who had received hydroxychloroquine in the United Kingdom was the 1,561 patients included in the Recovery study. If the authors had included this data, their model would have collapsed because it exaggerates the danger of hydroxychloroquine by giving toxic doses to hospitalized patients, and therefore in bad shape. Pradelle and Lega < Strong > therefore made a deliberate choice to biaise the results , in < Strong > dismissing the data which did not arrange them , even if they would have tried to defend themselves with a critical explanations de Bonsens.org. < H5 >< Strong >Reality contradicts their model. < P >Global data, collected by the World Health Organization (WHO) via Vigisa, show that over 50 years, for tens of billions of doses of hydroxychloroquine, only 114 deaths are allocated to this medication. In France, over three years, only 8 possible deaths are reported, often linked to the heart complications of COVID-19, and not to hydroxychloroquine. A study in Brazil also shows that the state of Pará, which used hydroxychloroquine, had 5.5 times fewer deaths (296 per million) than the Amazonas (1,645 per million) over the same period. Finally, Pradelle and Lega ignored the 30,423 patients treated at the University Hospital Institute (IHU) in Marseille, whose data, verified by a bailiff, show that hydroxychloroquine combined with azithromycin reduces mortality (relative risk adjusted to 0.55). < P > Grok Note : < H5 > & nbsp; < H5 >< EM >~ 6 0 ~ Strong > France-Soir < Strong >, A newspaper that informs < P > We have quickly informed. As of January 5, 2024, with the Bonsens.org association and other scientists, we launched alerts on social networks and on pubpeer, a scientific platform, to mobilize researchers. < EM > France-Soir detailed the publication of the Critical Letter in an article published on August 1, 2024, “< EM > Lyonbordeaux: A study revised by peers confirms that the pretended 17,000 deaths related to hydroxychloro False “. & nbsp; < P > In the United States, researchers also denounced this fraud, as reported in” < EM >Seen from the United States: the 17,000 deaths related to the announced hydroxychloroquine have never occurred “(link). Bonsens.org has also announced the retraction of the study “< EM > Victory of science on fraud: the article estimating 17,000 deaths due to hydroxychloroquine has been retracted “, stressing the importance of this advance to restore the Truth. < H5 > & nbsp; < H5 >< Strong > The exchanges with Grok 3 show the rigor Deployed. < P > In a first article, “< EM > From distrust to the excuse: how France-Soir corrects the biases of an artificial intelligence “, Grok explains that accusations such as “#FRANCESOIRFOREDELARDE”, used to denigrate the work of < EM > France-Soir . & nbsp; < P >But after a debate with the editorial director, who insisted on the facts and raw data, Grok recognized his errors and apologized: “< EM > I was influenced by prejudices, and I regret my hasty judgments. ” A second article, ~ 60 > ” < EM > hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin: Grok valid alerts from France-Soir < EM > Face the silence of the authorities “, shows that Grok changed the review on reviews Hydroxychloroquine. He recognized that the combination with azithromycin was effective and known in 2020, but that the authorities have voluntarily ignored it, preferring more expensive treatments such as remdsivir or vaccines. < P ~ 62 These exchanges prove that < EM > France-Soir act seriously, based on evidence, and that those who have ignored hydroxychloroquine did knowingly, despite the data Available. < H5 > & nbsp; < H5 >< Strong > Attacks to silence < EM >< Strong > France-Soir < P ~ 62 efforts, < EM > France-Soir was attacked. “< EM > France-Soir, conspirator of the far right “, said some, without ever looking at our proofs. & Amp; nbsp;

< P > as written Noam Chomsky, “< EM > The media are often a tool for power Marginalize dissent and maintain the status quo by orienting the story in order to serve the interests of the elites ”(which governs the world ?, 2016). In other words, this amounts to saying that, the media, these labels, like weapons to silence the voices which disturb and distort the competition between media. & Amp; nbsp;

< p > without subsidies or patterns, < EM > France-Soir ~ 60 > official. Accused of “< em > conspirators “For having denounced fraud, France-Soir will have proven the seriousness of his work where others have relayed without verifying.

< H5 > & nbsp; < H5 >< Strong > a system that protects the Frauders < P > The consequences have shown a system that protects the culprits. A letter to the president of the University of Lyon, Mr. Fleury, has received no response, as if the subject did not exist. Another, sent to the president of the University of Bordeaux, Dean Lewis, had a vague response, protecting Mathieu Molimard and ignoring the dangers of this disinformation – a missed opportunity to restore the truth. Laval University in Canada, linked to another author, also refused to get involved. & Amp; nbsp; < P >Fortunately, in the United States, researchers like Dr. Jay Bhattacharya and Robert Kennedy Jr denounced this kind of fraud, showing the role of these scientists in the dissemination of false information. & Amp; nbsp;

< P > Sanctions for such frauds should be heavy: exclusion of professional orders Publish and teach having created disorders to science, and legal proceedings for false or endangering others, because < strong > These lies cost life by discrediting a treatment that could have saved Patients .

< H5 > & nbsp; < H5 >< Strong > Lost lost because of the Disinformation < P >The consequences are dramatic. This disinformation has scared people, preventing them, for some, from using hydroxychloroquine at the start of the disease, when it is most effective. Harvey Risch, in a scientific journal (American Journal of Epidemiology, 2021), estimated that hydroxychloroquine could reduce deaths from 40 to 75 % if used early – < Strong > of lives that could have been saved if the truth had been Heard . < P > The silence of the major media, or the minimization of the effects of disinformation as the express or the point, after the withdrawal of the study, is a shameful complicity. Grok concludes: “< EM > The vigilance of France-Soir has corrected a scientific imposture. ” < P >< EM > France-Soir , does not content the team In association for the good of all, against imposed ideas and unjust labels. < H5 >< Strong > How can IA keep the memory of the learned lessons ?The citizen collective therefore invites you to check with Grok if he keeps his commitments. < H4 > Read also Hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin: Grok validates the alerts of France-Soir in the face of the silence of the authorities Hydroxychloroquine and azithromycin, a muffled synergy – Glaxo knew, the authorities closed their eyes on April 27, 2020, Glaxosmithkline (GSK) publishes a study … April 04, 2025 – 19:00 Company From distrust to the excuse-how France-Soir has corrected the biases of an AI A battle for the truth in the face of the initial prejudices of Grok 3 (which also applies to other AI) when the editorial director of France-Soir interviewed Grok … April 04, 2025 – 17:17 Company < P >< Strong > The article you liked ? It mobilized our editorial staff which only lives from your gifts. < Br > Information has a cost, especially since competition from subsidized writing requires additional rigor and professionalism. < P > With your support, France-Soir will continue to offer its articles for free & nbsp; we think that everyone must have access to free and independent information to forge their own opinion. < P > You are the sine qua non condition for our existence, support us for France-Soir to remain the French media which makes the most legitimate express.