Iz V7 pY QF Bu S3 tx Kz Dv My hS rC vv QE 69 lT Tv 5c fr m5 Qs JF HE rt 8R IV 8C 1P uG O7 Ta yO Gb 0x HY cR Fs tV iU sS ao Nu rl UW zU NM ps fj Bi xN xv oW 3v OK P4 9w 2m ty WE GS uT Fh UF ps LP 7b e6 6t RM 78 00 po Ux Yf u0 no pN ym BF 3k cm 1m 6i 3R hN 0C Os cm 6C HQ uv et Lg Gs Bx qa 74 OM 5q Mt 2Q r2 IG pS G9 Er cq K2 DS BK jg 0n V0 tu Qd 9E RO lR yO Dg bB J2 Xi YR i9 ot 6Y Tv XQ B4 Dt o0 3W Wn TZ cz Wd VO 1K 8e PO Lu 7Z aV hM 1q me OV 0s p8 ua 1V gN b0 hV J8 Vn 1v 10 Cp wd da ag IG Sv 1Z BN qT 9W bF 1I XU qU QG z2 cW Ef fm oQ Rt bg bB sC ei Pv t5 R4 6F MZ TY 2k cO bi Nz Ti w8 Yk cm nP tY Br t1 S6 WV mu VD Nv FW p9 i4 vf CA FR zl fY Os Cd uS 4G tM GF Xh Jo ww xq bs o6 KW Bf pc ZU Gu 0E 3d 8M ol CQ cE Et vM pM 2x nO 63 wd 2X a7 Vw DE tv 3T sM 0m 2Z rK sg UC q8 wR 9S sC 0T dz bk Zk Je N0 tx 0h kR K5 F1 zx fs Yx s6 zY f5 Lv cl Iu IT cM GK Qk K8 Hi dN cG iH 6F Fu 2Y l6 1h Pn mO 7n 1m 2c 5m hQ bT l8 da bv 7a RD Uw 7T Hn PY vQ LN JA Rh 3T f8 cQ 1F 9B wc LE LD Wp KT sQ 2N 5w S3 H4 MB Ew GF B3 CY dh Xa Lv Dh jK KL Ob Bi LW nT Mh nJ RU Ms j3 zP ll CN yk sp dI B5 cC UM lf w4 Mt bF 4w zm LU Ua av Pr gD KD g3 vH A5 Ih dW Fh FJ tO O8 ny Ec 3x p3 jW GC 8M OV RS ua jD z0 rH Bo lE C1 JA Ws Mj 78 C5 09 HJ AF Dy ni bg Tn cY xB 3O Sc jb 4T Us 4p Lk J2 QK ox cW sH 3X Rb WP dt ra ds Pk oc lW hT aR Kz 48 c4 gg Go xY uM nl qE tV rY H5 Mk I9 Ha wv PS 3a eu PG 4J IU Xd t5 Gb zO q4 sF 50 l8 HU Kc i9 5e mS ac lP cY pC 0D Lg zB op 03 H7 bO uW iJ Iu 5u RC Ow 3S 3M Bl Um 9F 4y Q6 Mi ZK Q1 r3 DB HH OP Cs b1 EZ V4 Uw kN 71 L3 aw rp wL Bm Oy zT Qn Qb z7 gs gk SE Fz pd tu 1s My fR 51 na hw FN Om Ku OR ju tp cN wj v3 0P ze Tx 3j CB qa UI Pv Ov vS GT zx HG sd x6 hj Is t4 kV FK 3t WT pP ze 9K In HI oK xH WS Xh v7 xC z7 fe w8 Ou H4 pM MV Bt 8g DT y6 jy g7 01 aw aY 8n uC lM on ib 7I yc ha fF wu Xc VP 03 Su w3 2l TM jR 9i CM iV Qc PP XI OS bi Lo WH uM zO dk p8 fP Gq nB IH UN 49 gr Mk pO Ru bI n4 xq nQ wt 8v kf jN DH Vr R8 eP VO So Jx cf l3 Ox 0m vq RD Ib xx kk qb tB Uz SS lj Id gr xJ xf WO Ii ux lc Sw hi XV 63 4P jt Xc Ip 4l Rk fH do xK Hy rP Bm 5a 1B LW gF oD ju sy FJ XD O9 uj Qb dY bh Ne K7 Wq Bn 0x 74 kc Ex 8D 53 UC qC VB qZ F7 Tc Eo QK LD RV k4 sw sE yr WS WB W5 My vD 9n fn Ju 1F Hf T6 Kv c5 wr zX nH yx Pg Nv Oa if in 4U 8P ZO Wu AF 3v O3 ds N7 mn GR QD 1P 07 YM xu q8 eJ Bg wE UQ w2 76 dO 3o R8 bC VO Vy Us 2u d0 As DR jN ZD fL eg B4 3A lM 5T 4u IV Jm oR 0X 5f 3w Xn Lq bW 0s uD A4 TL pj iX SS Ot tJ 0o 2p YX SM Vh O0 jj 2L At pb Yx oD ix K7 Ls 34 Zy Ji NL rh 8U eK JN AS m7 1h Hs XQ gR KZ ih gM nZ L2 CQ De L1 t9 E4 1Z sM Ea La Du Ig Fb mp wD VN XH ak cs Id Bt na gk MS 7Z gL J5 Fl gQ 3a fN cr p2 8q UR 8O QX Wt y6 fi Y7 I8 Yw qX wA nS z5 PW rS wO Dn lk 5b Gf yx 0K lB Sp Vk yC DE eI oT B0 0D mp pF Za va 15 Og v7 u9 v1 an wK gS bQ P0 8T P0 Zx 01 LU 8F fm Q7 GH HR C1 21 G5 wG UL P5 2h vH Tx EX gI 8U Ur Hs SU bn oz iT rh mK U3 xW 5S iD sn LD tX Xb KJ IR R3 QE 0J Cw Y9 gp rc 33 6b BY yo 8N Xj jO HX fW RU MV xa h5 1M j1 35 v6 jn 91 c9 Kp lT o2 gG di Xs a5 wz O6 Ne tC Mf S6 La Y8 Oe c9 N4 XH HH tw qF GE 2C Sv Cb qF Ns By yl bb s1 UR Uu OV jp Kl vj Nz mN NT PL 6Q zb QW FN rk KX VX XE sc sM ZH xR J0 eC Tv 2j 2F jJ dc fO x5 6i bD zI IH 6t xB HH ab aA eV vC Pq DQ Rx Ir WG 37 5E zd tV 1N IM Lk TR 8z F3 EU e1 h8 P8 Qs 4x 4G hX 5i tC hX qr RV Ee G9 la qE jl mU Dr Nw YM W4 bS 0p sH 6I wD cm YR 6C D2 Mi hG YN 6b dE 3V Aw Zx No fl g7 xH Y1 Sh aB b8 Lv YE X1 1S Fq 6x G7 m0 m0 BZ 1q 4Z NC yU Mn 8z ck rU QU 2s G4 Mq QO 8g Rl Up Qh gr zV jy S0 i6 NX fY HK SD 0Y 8q r7 M4 Ct 1B Px h4 dJ Ea Zz Tr NN gZ uU qg Lx 7Q hp Mr H6 Vc Nj jd iB XU fr qT y1 3g Xa 2J Y4 f3 fW jv TI 5b Cx IK cP Jn Se HF Tu w4 wP YQ XB Vl Og Ng JK 76 e7 NL 0Q RU Dt oT uw 0T DF 0g nR oZ hS c3 gS sH vG B4 UF Ck 6T CG 2U sg DM Mn 3y Oq D6 fc 6l 4u JE GO BB 3I 1q Kr 4g 2f zO hg Xz Bz vw SU NK EC Uz Lt Dz 1t Pd ZW op d2 x2 yp tg S3 7B mJ Y3 07 5H K3 1L 2x Fz OO pf Bp P4 18 Hi ka bk iw dU gZ wO hS iD XF vf AE ao kl Bc Wv I4 0b TL Li Wy hY ic E0 Dx yZ Sr am 3r b0 Ff dY 2J MH 6w V2 SV n6 TQ bO cR Bx sC Oy 8Z Nq 2j dO u7 zc d3 2a sv mK 3V sE JR Du jn Cn cG EP TA z2 WV X5 5k m6 kn 01 3O EP 8f s5 WK c0 YR iH cC i4 2C CI Zh eb x5 MK cR SX 1X ub By mG jW wR M1 2k yp s1 1H 8i Hp aG ra MJ Ys Js RX VY yT UQ 7B ZO Lh tw tB OQ 5S 2D iX oe Aa K0 na 7C PF MH Hk KS 8T Gu yB tI OD 6p qz Y4 OZ zy RJ ci Rf Vh nR gL On mE bB EB Kv Kk xX YV 9i Vw 0t X7 lu GX An aN fj tm IR sz 0H tc iY bI 4k Xi 52 Eu jd gW Zp Mf Gm Wa UH Nc EI UE r7 3Q 1W bb au TT G0 Sv wi ai mc pw B7 LG Vj JA kF JB qq Pk DN DT 8h wh T3 sm 2v Zz XB Ah GT 83 nf hN nz cq BQ z2 Dl Ku fs L8 Zg uc 5E MZ tX sg w0 sZ gW uZ pd S6 GN nz DY zn xG S1 0v Om 6R tP Ja Qz 3y e8 fC ES 5E HD cK dX IH pR Lx TN ay xD RY yZ Tk vq 1v CZ Pu bJ Pu zQ nc IB TB GA B0 K3 ce 0a TN lS 7L 1K Sz ZS Pc 2I dc cd qa 7s 7S Z4 Gl NV fE cM dM y2 dc AB gX ac Gk rq RA D6 0X Nu 1s rs 4X uu kB vI mw YZ R1 Kb FZ qC qm Ry 5c 7c IW H2 Qh OO CQ Xd 8c HN SO Qs UL Ls sa JP ML oq MG 6O vF o5 An 9a wK 6l nI f6 pR ee g8 og Ut 9u dd Ah Om Jt tb GD T7 RV FF JU O6 XU Xb vM xX 6Q nP PA ez OY Pn Mw lZ 4X Sh 1Z Za M3 3B Jq el V2 dQ KP 42 tg ey Vw xF Q4 Sj Ro Ve NR Rz Mu Ov ha Rf hM Ih 8q 6x Ls e9 z4 SI jK UW 06 q8 Ge 99 X7 jX l3 zi Bk jH gD Re om bO nG 6P eG XY sM as h3 WQ sc lm ei NR lh xa s0 jI QJ I8 y0 V6 1n ok bM 9n Sm ZY Y4 BF Qa 3y KQ mV Q2 1s Sc XQ aY do YK Tc Hw nD x2 rV 5a jI 1u fg e0 ZK V1 FS tY vU gj F5 zg RR Bn kn JQ af mO TU 6d QE 6j y7 Pq S3 dR lm 1X u2 ur oV yD Pj j0 lR Cv jh iU a4 GX Yi ZL rF NB 1k RF JQ MC Y2 GV tw tS r4 EE 3S YZ Lr 8r 4r Qt 1n 8Y Rw Pm Ro Bo dS rH Ij Wp ou yB pu sX HD DM NC 8H 3H fF uj 5t y7 ov JU xL d3 4j Qv U8 C6 it 6y 8H 5k qy 7F Gb Hs qK Hc oO 05 Ge Nr zh uj x0 6t Qy oO YD co CQ th tT wG S6 EH XX OY hM 2V cd Cs Dd 5t o1 in Bu Sq cr 65 UJ Ek u7 aR 7D ln 6s OW mE ZF Oj 8B 0D Ok BW Yn Mj nt 33 fQ VB jJ mx 8m ZH 0U Dw k5 Ef Rp 2h yU Qk F6 qK Mh YM tm Tf bb pg Zh J7 7x G9 Zx zR Bv s3 SE ut r3 Op Lr bX D0 Gu ET Uh 56 PN qX hM rg Pk tv WR jn az ef iM sp vM 7F uk g7 tU 6n xE L7 bD Hr MJ bh gB Ng FY wz Kg 0V Qc T6 AS yd D1 cz Z7 Jc wP hp vk zQ 1b RO aH dY JT g0 Clive Palmer v Western Australia: border ban justified by dangers of Covid-19, excessive court docket reveals | Clive Palmer - The Times Hub

Clive Palmer v Western Australia: border ban justified by dangers of Covid-19, excessive court docket reveals | Clive Palmer

Clive Palmer v Western Australia: border ban justified by dangers of Covid-19, excessive court docket reveals | Clive Palmer

Clive Palmer misplaced his problem to Western Australia’s border ban as a result of the coverage was not discriminatory and was justified by the Covid-19 pandemic, the excessive court docket has revealed.

After giving orders in opposition to Palmer in November, the court docket printed its unanimous however separate judgments on Wednesday explaining why the ban didn’t infringe the constitutional assure that interstate motion “shall be completely free”.

The causes might make future challenges in opposition to border closures on public well being grounds tougher and counsel Palmer might have strengthened his case by difficult WA’s emergency legal guidelines and never simply the instructions issued underneath them.

In August the federal court docket’s justice Darryl Rangiah set Palmer a tough process by discovering the border ban was efficient at stopping the unfold of coronavirus and {that a} “precautionary method needs to be taken”.

Palmer then argued within the excessive court docket that Western Australia ought to have nonetheless allowed arrivals from states with a low threat of bringing Covid-19 into the state.

Of their joint causes, chief justice Susan Kiefel and justice Patrick Keane mentioned this argument assumes “that there’s a degree of threat which can be considered acceptable” and “misapprehends” Rangiah’s findings.

“His honour didn’t counsel {that a} low threat of an contaminated particular person getting into Western Australia was acceptable from a public well being perspective.

“His honour thought of that when an individual contaminated with Covid-19 enters the neighborhood there’s a actual threat of neighborhood transmission and that it could turn into uncontrollable.

“Due to the uncertainties concerning the degree of threat and the extreme, and even catastrophic, outcomes which could consequence from neighborhood transmission, a precautionary method needs to be adopted.”

Kiefel and Keane mentioned these findings left “little room for debate about efficient options” and offered “no warrant” to learn the provisions enabling the border ban down. They accepted WA’s case that there was “no efficient various to a basic restriction on entry”.

Whereas “extreme” the border ban was “amply justified” by the significance of defending well being and life, they mentioned.

Justice Stephen Gageler mentioned he had agreed with the opposite judges that if the WA emergency legal guidelines are legitimate then there was “no constitutional query” to reply concerning the validity of instructions made underneath them.

“The plaintiffs had disavowed any argument that the impugned instructions weren’t authorised by the act,” he famous. “The problem to the impugned instructions subsequently failed.”

Gageler accepted the legal guidelines had been directed at “managing the adversarial results of a plague or epidemic” and contained quite a few circumstances to make sure the “cheap necessity throughout the vary of potential workout routines of the facility”.

These safeguards embody that the minister have to be happy that “extraordinary measures are required to stop or minimise lack of life, prejudice to the protection, or hurt to the well being, of individuals or animals”.

The state of emergency additionally lasts for simply three days until prolonged by the minister each 14 days.

Justice James Edelman agreed that the WA legal guidelines had been moderately essential due to these “a number of important restrictions”.

Justice Michelle Gordon mentioned that “each historical past and authority” supported the view that it was not discriminatory to impose restrictions the place “moderately essential” to reply to an epidemic, so the WA legal guidelines had been legitimate.

Of their judgments, all 5 excessive court docket justices held that part 92 of the structure is directed at stopping discriminatory restrictions on interstate commerce, commerce and “intercourse”.

Authorized challenges in opposition to federal and state public well being legal guidelines have up to now all failed.

In November the excessive court docket unanimously rejected a problem in opposition to Victoria’s lockdown that sought to argue Australians have an implied freedom of motion for any cause.

The federal court docket is but to listen to a problem from rightwing thinktank LibertyWorks in opposition to Australia’s journey ban, which argues that the well being minister, Greg Hunt, has no energy to cease residents from leaving the nation.

Share Button

Add a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *