< IMG LOADING = "Lazy" SRSC = "/Sites/Default/Files/Styles/Medium/Public/2025-04/Image%20article%20%2855%29.jpg ? Itok = U1_E-8EV" Width = "1280" Height = "720" 2025 "Class =" Lazyload IMG-Fluid Image-Style-Max-300x1300 "SRC ="/Sites/Default/Files/Styles/Max_1300x1300/Public/2025-04/Image%20article%20%2855%29.jpg ? iTok = Owsdt2xr "/ Berliner Zeitung, France-Soir Cavid vaccines and opacity: a crisis of confidence that continues-what do we hide title ? A tribune of Berliner Zeitung < P > CE April 21, 2025, an article by Berliner Zeitung entitled “< EM > The chemists question the vaccines against the coronavirus: what is concealment ?(Link) highlights the concerns of five European chemists on mRNA vaccines against the COVVI-19. These scientists, from prestigious universities, denounce the opacity of the European authorities, in particular of the European Agency for Medicines (EMA) and the Paul-Ehrlich-Institut (PEI), in the management of data on these vaccines. While the pandemic seems behind us, the questions on the transparency of the approval and vaccine control processes persist. Why do the authorities refuse to disclose crucial information, even three years after the deployment of vaccines ? The revelations of the chemists be put in perspective in relation to previous leaks & nbsp; Population & nbsp; ?
< H5 > & nbsp; < H5 >< Strong > Context and approach of chemists Germans < P >Since February 2022, five renowned chemists from the universities of Leipzig, Bochum, Tübingen, Zurich and Erlangen have undertaken a quest for transparency. Specialists in analytical and organic chemistry, they sent information requests to EMA and PEI, based on < Strong > The right to freedom of information (IFG in Germany). Their objective is not < Strong > Oppose the vaccines , but < Strong > Understand their exact composition , Les < Strong > tolerances Potential impacts on public health . They wish to answer fundamental questions: what substances are present in vaccines ? what variations are accepted in lots ? & nbsp; < H5 > & nbsp; < H5 >< Strong > Many obstacles encountered < P >After three years of waiting, the EMA provided documents to chemists, but they are heavily cavited, making information unusable. For example, tables on manufacturing tolerances are masked under the pretext of “commercial secrets”. A German chemist residing in the European Economic Area is < Strong > even given any response , despite the right of access to guaranteed information to the citizens of the EU. Furthermore, disclosed documents circulating on a Dutch site reveal < Strong > Information not cavilated , as the presence of < Strong > sodium sulfate – A banal compound – Masked by EMA, while EMA, The EDTA, potentially more reactive, is left visible. & nbsp; < P > these < Strong > inconsistencies feed suspicions Chemists, who have filed an appeal against roles and a complaint against the PEI before the Darmstadt administrative court, waiting since March 2023. < H5 > & nbsp; < H5 >< Strong > Scientific questions Raised < P > Disclored documents reveal alarming tolerances: < Strong > The quantity of active mRNM can vary up to 400 % from one batch to the other 62 > 62 ~ 62. Chemists question the implications of such variations: how do they affect the effectiveness of vaccines or side effects ? They cite the principle of paracelse, “the dose makes the poison”, to underline the importance of precision in pharmaceutical products. They also note that similar data has been made public in the United States thanks to the Freedom of Information Act, contrasting with European opacity. & Amp; nbsp; < P > Finally, they criticize the lack of independent control: PEI is limited to checking the optical properties of vaccines according to the European Pharmacopoeia, < Strong > A method deemed insufficient to guarantee the quality of the lots. < H5 > & nbsp; < H5 >< Strong ~ 62 Perspective < Ul > Li > Les < Strong > Pfizer Leaks and the integrity problems of the RNA : The concerns of chimists are not new. From January 2021, leaks of internal documents from Pfizer, relayed by < EM > France-Soir , revealed problems < Strong > of integrity of the mRNA in Biontech/Pfizer vaccines. An internal email, dated November 23, 2020, pointed out a significant difference in < Strong >The integrity of the mRNA between clinical lots (approximately 78 %) and commercial lots (approximately 55 %) . & nbsp; < br > the author, Korakianiti Evdokia, stressed that this degradation could affect the effectiveness of the vaccine, which is based on an intact mRNM Spike. At the time, the world had minimized these leaks, saying that they did not call into question the safety of vaccines. However, the revelations of 2025 show that < Strong > These integrity problems have not been resolved and that < Strong > High tolerances (up to 400 %) persist, < Strong > confirm the Initial fears of the pfizer leaks . < br > & nbsp;< li >< Strong > Quality control of early treatments : ? The question of quality control is not limited to vaccines. Another article of < EM > France-Soir Published in 2021 explores early treatments against COVVI-19, such as hydroxychloroquine and ivermectine, often excluded for the benefit of vaccines. The authorities have applied < Strong > extremely strict control standards for these treatments , < Strong > Contrastant with the laxity observed for vaccines & nbsp; ? Hydroxychloroquine have been suspended for minor side effects, while variations in the integrity of the mRNA in vaccines have not caused similar measures. & nbsp; < br >< br > This disparity could reflect < Strong > a political prioritization of Vaccines As “the only solution” to the crisis, to the detriment of an equitable assessment of the alternatives. Although the data on the quality control of early treatments are limited, this difference in treatment raises questions on the consistency of regulatory policies. < br > & nbsp;
< li >< Strong > The variations between lots and the vibeke manniche. A study conducted by Dr Vibeke Manniche, published in 2023 in the European Journal of Clinical Investigation (link), provides additional light on the quality variations of vaccines. Analyzing the Danish data of the reported side effects, Manniche and its team identified a < Strong > significant correlation between certain prizes of vaccines Pfizer/BionTech and < Strong > An increased number of side effects Graves . & nbsp; < br >< Br > as explained Manniche in an interview at < EM > France-Soir 62 > 62 >(link), these variations could be linked to differences in manufacturing processes, corroborating the concerns of chemists on high tolerances (up to 400 %). This study underlines that < Strong > The absence of rigorous quality control a potentially exposed < Strong > Certain populations at increased risks , reinforcing the urgency of transparency Total. & nbsp; < br >~ 60 > This is also confirmed by the declarations of side effects in a survey < EM > France-Soir /Bonsens.org on a representative sample of 1200 French & nbsp; Base of the declarative of side effects, potentially demonstrating the significant difference in pharmacovigilance under declaration – a constant problem observed and studied for a long time by specialists. < br >< img data-entity-uuid = "CB43AB7B-E443-4FE4-86C7-D723F9638474" Data-entity-Type = "File" Width = "945" Height = "532" Loading = "Lazy" class = "Lazyload" SRC = "/Sites/Default/Files/Inline -Images/Image_246.png" >< br > & Nbsp; < li >< Strong > Opacity of contracts With more than 1000 complainants, Baldan seized European justice, arguing that this censorship violated the right of citizens to information. < Br > Baldan and the 1000 complainants finally obtained the contracts but have still not disclosed their content. According to him, reading contracts show that the authorities have masked important elements to the public and the professional. This example shows that cavilating, denounced by chemists for technical data, also extends to contractual aspects, strengthening the impression of systematic concealment. < br > & nbsp;
< li > a < Strong > opacity Citizens . A survey < EM > France-Soir /Bonsens.org of February 2025 on a representative sample of 1200 French, shows that 79 % find that < Strong >These are citizens who had to fight to obtain transparency on vaccine contracts, but more important established that 64 % believe that “& nbsp; < EM > if the decision -making bodies that go to us did not have access to contracts before making a decision, < Strong > Have acted in the interest of the citizen “. < br >< br >< img data-entity-uuid =" 440703E1-6CCB-4218-A120-008642B231ba " Data-entity-Type = "File" Width = "945" Height = "348" Loading = "Lazy" Class = "Lazyload" SRC = "/Sites/Default/Files/Inline-Images/Image_247.png" >< H5 > & nbsp; < H5 >< Strong > Reactions and wider implications < P >Faced with the opacity of the authorities, the chemists intensified their actions, making appeal against the EMA and continuing the PEI in court. Their fight, combined with initiatives like that of Frédéric Baldan, highlights a crisis of growing confidence in health institutions. The absence of transparency-whether production data or contracts-fuels doubts about vaccine safety and health crisis management.
< P > This lack of clarity contrasts with the United States, where similar data has been made public under legal pressure. More broadly, this case questions the responsibility of the regulatory authorities: how to guarantee public security without access to complete data ? & nbsp;< H5 > & nbsp; < H5 >< Strong > What risks ?< P > Les < Strong > Revelations des chemists, combined with pfizer leaks and < Strong > Contracts show that arnm integrity problems were known in 2020, but were not corrected. High tolerances in vaccines (up to 400 %) were able to expose the population to poorly evaluated risks, in particular variations in efficiency and unpredictable side effects. & Amp; nbsp;
< P > Furthermore, the < Strong > laxity in quality control < H5 >< Br >< Br > Note: < Strong > Complete translation of the article 62 > 62 > 62< Strong > Berliner Zeitung, April 21, 2025 ~ 60 > “Chemiker Fragen Zu Corona-Impfffen: was zum teufel sol werden ? “< br > & nbsp; < P > of chemists question on vaccines against the coronavirus: what devil wants to hide ?> P > Five chemists wish Lightening on the part of the European Medicines Agency on Arnm vaccines. After three years, they receive cavilated documents. < P >< EM > It is an & nbsp; contribution & nbsp; < EM > OPEN Source < EM > & nbsp;. The Berline Verlag publishing house offers all interested parties the & nbsp; < EM > Possibility < EM > & Nbsp; to offer texts with relevant content and quality standards Professionals. < P >According to the & Nbsp; Law on Freedom of Information (IFG), & nbsp; everyone has the right to access the official information of the federal authorities. But what is the IFG really worth in practice ? Why can the health authorities delay the publication of the documents requested for years ? and why, when the documents are ultimately published, are they generally masked to the point of being unrecognizable, even if additional information has since become available on an international scale ? 62 > 62 > 62 > 62 ~ 62Since February 2022, we, as a group of chemistry and physics teachers, have been trying to obtain information on mRNA vaccines from our national and European authorities. We are particularly interested in the methods of analytical measurement for the quality assurance of vaccines and the tolerances of integrity and concentration of the ingredients. < P > To our knowledge, this information is not the commercial and business secrecy of manufacturers, but are provided to the latter by the authorities. The supreme authority responsible for the approval of drugs, also in Germany, is the & nbsp; < EM > European agency of drugs & nbsp; (EMA), which, according to its own internal regulations relating to the law on freedom of information, allows each citizen of the EU to request two documents, which must be provided within two years. We asked for important documents for the public in April 2022. < P >After three years (!), They are sent to us in small pieces. A few months ago, a question was asked to find out if we really needed these documents after such a long period. A German colleague living in a “EEE country” has been denied any information, while any EU citizen should be entitled to information. < br > & nbsp; < IMG Data-Bntity-Type = "File" Data-Bntity-Uuid = "EA983A30-670E-4E5D-A0BE-CD5E2F92F923C2D" Height = "630" Width = "945" LOADING = "Lazy" Class = "Lazyload" SRC = "/Sites/Default/Files/Inline-Images/Image_248.png" > < EM > Example 1: Table of the EMA document requested within the framework of IFG (right): the relevant information is blackened. < P >The documents received from the EMA are now so blackened (see examples 1 to 3) that they are completely devoid of value compared to the information requested. We opposed the full drafting of documents. We are surprised that the authorized tolerances set by the authorities are masked by the argument of “protection of the manufacturer's trade”, while, for example, the quantitative composition (target values) of the preparations is actually published. One might have the impression that the eligible tolerances are so high that we do not want to disclose them to the authorities in order to avoid having to provide solid scientific justifications. < img alt = "image bz2" data-entitith-type = "file" data-entity-uuid = "660ac438-958c-4a0e-ac8b-41efecd76cdc" height = "630" Width = "945" Loading = "Lazy" SRC = "/Sites/Default/Files/Inline-Images/Image_249.png" > < EM > Example 2: Table of the EMA document requested within the framework of IFG (right): the relevant information is blackened. < P >Information probably no longer has any value in terms of protection, as documents disclosed (see left -wing tables in examples 1 to 3) containing the requested information has long been circulating on the Internet, for example on this Dutch website (& nbsp; nbsp;). We can therefore reasonably assume, for example, that in a document which has been sent to us, the sodium sulfate substance has been blackened – an agent of filling in detergents, a laxative in medicine – while the EDTA, which is also not very toxic and a complex agent with greater potential for biological interaction, has remained unmanned. Anyone who wishes can include the decision -making process behind. < P >In addition, we know, thanks to disclosed documents, that the amount of active mRNA can vary from a factor of approximately 4, or about 400 %. But why were such tolerances allowed ? Isn't there a better way to do technologically ? Will manufacturing become too expensive with lower tolerances ? What effect does such a high tolerance have on efficiency and side effects ? It is not for the dose. Before the House of Military Complaints of the Federal Administrative Court of Leipzig, in the summer of 2022, Dr. W., the main examiner of the PEI, also cited figures corresponding to the documents disclosed. This information is also available in the United States, where it had to be published following a request under & nbsp; < EM > Law on the freedom of information & nbsp; by court decision (order of the tribunal attached in pdf) (& nbsp; here & nbsp;). < br > & nbsp; < img alt = "image bz3" data-entitith-type = "File" data-entity-uuid = "F861C66B-D79D-4CBe-8e97-5188a67a1f10" Height = "630" Width = "945" Loading = "Class" SRC = "/Sites/Default/Files/Inline-Images/Image_250.png" > < EM > Example 3: Table of the EMA document requested within the framework of IFG (right): the relevant information is blackened. Private < P >Before this farce with the EMA, we had already contacted the German Federal Institute for Vaccines and Biomedics, the Paul Ehrlich Institute (PEI), to obtain the publication of relevant information for the public. & Amp; nbsp; nbsp; the Berliner Zeitung reported this (here) since February 2022. We have received an opinion dated July 27, 2022, indicating that they do not wish to provide us with this information, invoking data protection problems concerning the manufacturing process. We have tabled an objection, which was rejected by the IPE, invoking the need to protect the manufacturer's secrets. In March 2023, we filed a complaint against this with the Darmstadt administrative court on the basis of IFG. The PEI has appointed a law firm in Frankfurt to defend itself and quoted to appear a manufacturing company. We have been waiting for the start of procedures for two good years. Until now, we still have no information as to the date on which this procedure will be finally opened. < P >But Prince Edward Island did not leave us completely unanswered. He informed us that the tests of optical properties are carried out in accordance with the European pharmacopoeia (EAB), section 2.9.22. However, this article deals with the measurement of the softening point of suppositories and is completely out of topic. An additional reference to section 2.2.2 (& nbsp; < EM > degree of coloring of liquids & nbsp;), which deals with the & nbsp; < EM > absorption & which overwhelmed authority does not take note of the fact that the impression of color of the new mRNA vaccines, which are aqueous dispersions of lipid nanoparticles largely colorless, is largely determined by the diffusion of light and less by the absorption of light.< p > 62 > 62 > 62 > 62 ~ 62So what do we know after three years of effort ? not much more than when we started asking questions. We know that the tolerance range for the value of the pH of the vaccines is of an entire unit, which corresponds to a factor of ten of the concentration of H3O+ ions described by the value of the pH and described to what extent the liquid dose form is acid, neutral or basic. One wonders why this tolerance was chosen so high given the lipid complex chemically quite unstable.
< P >In addition, we now know that the PEI only performs four experiments itself, which has also been confirmed by Dr. W .: (I) the color test with the naked eye, which we consider inappropriate to the highly diffusing substances of light, (ii) the pH test with its great tolerance, (iii) the length test of the mRNA, in which only half of the molic molecules must have the good length ( Great tolerance), since the others are supposed to be “inactive”, and (iv) the identity of the mRNA, which must be confirmed only on the basis of a few short sequences and must not apply to the whole mRNA. < P >Several laboratories have reported DNA contamination linked to production in the Biontech vaccine produced en masse. However, among these four methods, we cannot identify any method capable of detecting DNA contamination. In addition, the IPE declared in response to an information request that it did not test the amount of DNA contamination, but only checked if the quantity indicated by the manufacturer was located in the authorized beach. It has nothing to do with an independent audit. We also lack experiences of diffusion of light in the control list, which can test the properties of lipid nanoparticles. They are quick to achieve and give an idea of the compliance of the granulometric distribution of the sample to specifications. The modern methods that are at the cutting edge of technology, the sequencers said & nbsp; < EM > of new generation & nbsp;, although available at PEI, are not used either. Dr. W. said these modern methods are “very sensitive”. We, the authors of this text, consider sensitivity as highly desirable. < P >Even after three years of intensive effort, our questions about the quality of new mRNA vaccines did not find an answer. We have more and more the impression that the authorities will retain information for futile reasons. On the one hand, this will likely lead to a loss of confidence in these institutions. On the other hand, this strengthens the suspicion that the demands of the authorities in terms of drug safety are perhaps not as high as one might expect for dosage forms which have been and continue to be used in general by the vast majority of the population, that is to say by largely healthy people. How can the public have confidence in drug safety when questions about quality control lead to a massive refusal to provide information ?< P >IFG has apparently also mentioned in current coalition negotiations at the federal level. ZDF & nbsp; reported: Quote: & nbsp; < EM > “Reporters without borders” warns that the abolition of the law “would constitute a serious attack on freedom of information and therefore to our right to information to all. »& Amp; nbsp; end & nbsp; quote. IFG already seems to be a teddy tiger in many cases. Instead of further restricting the transparency of public authorities by removing IFG or limiting it, IFG reform should rather guarantee more complete and significantly faster access to information for all citizens. After all, transparency creates confidence. < P >< EM > Addendum of the authors: & nbsp; The President of the United States now puts to & Nbsp; . < P > prof. Dr. Jörg Matysik, Analytical Chemistry, University of Leipzig < P > Prof. Dr. Gerald Dyker, Organic Chemistry, University of Ruhr in Bochum < P > Prof. Dr. Andreas Schnepf, inorganic chemistry, University of Tübingen < P > Prof. Dr. Tobias Unruh, Physics, Fau Erlangen-Nuremberg < P > Prof. Dr. Martin Winkler, Engineering of Materials and Processes, University of Applied Sciences of Zurich < P >< EM > This is a contribution subject within the framework of our open source initiative. With & nbsp; < EM > open source, & nbsp; < EM > The Berlin publisher offers all interested parties Possibility & nbsp; de & nbsp; < EM > Propose texts with relevant content and professional quality standards < EM > & nbsp; & will be & nbsp; < em > published and honored < em > & nbsp; < H4 > Read also Pfizer had prepared everything, however! The Antwerp of the Depart for the Vaccine Delay Pfizer has announced that vaccine deliveries may be 3 to 4 weeks late due to work in the Puurs factory, in the province of Antwerp in Belgium … January 18, 2021 – 16:43 Company “There is a link between covid-19 and side effects” (Dr. Vibeke Manniche, PHD, and Max Schmeling) Debriefing – Vibeke Manniche (doctor) and Max Schmeling (Statistician) published an analysis on the links between the prizes of COVID vaccines and the side effects A … December 04, 2023 – 14:20 Videos Ursulagates & nbsp;: In addition to complaints aimed at Ursula von der Leyen, Frédéric Baldan and Diane Protat announce that he has filed a complaint against Laura Kövesi, EPPO head Despite the numerous maneuvers of the EPPO (European Public Prosecutor Office), the omerta of most of the media, the vice seems to tighten around Ursula von der Leye … December 08, 2024 – 15:15 Policy < P >< Strong > The article you liked ? It mobilized our editorial staff which only lives from your gifts. < Br > Information has a cost, especially since competition from subsidized writing requires additional rigor and professionalism. < P > With your support, France-Soir will continue to offer its articles for free & nbsp; we think that everyone must have access to free and independent information to forge their own opinion. < P > You are the sine qua non condition for our existence, support us for France-Soir to remain the French media which makes the most legitimate express.